Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles

Pros, Cons, Comparisons, and Costs

If you are considering putting a new roof on your home or your business, you may be wondering about the benefits and drawbacks of two of the most popular roofing materials: metal roofing and asphalt shingles.

To be sure, there are advantages and disadvantages to each of these options. Within this article, you will find a comparison of the costs, the protection, durability, and the impact that both types of common roofing materials will have on the resale value of your property.

Metal Roof vs Asphalt Shingles: A Comprehensive Breakdown

Initial Costs

Undoubtedly, you want to know the immediate cost of putting up a new roof on your home or business. Of course, these costs can vary widely — as it will depend on the size and complexity of your projects as well as the specific materials that you choose to work with. Notably, the initial costs of installing asphalt shingles on your roof are less than for a metal roof.

This is the biggest pro associated with asphalt shingles: the upfront costs are lower. As a general benchmark, asphalt shingles are somewhere between 50 percent and 65 percent cheaper than metal roofing is on a per square foot basis. Though, to be clear, that is only true when considering the initial costs. As metal roofing has a far longer lifespan, the long-term costs of metal roofing can actually be less expensive.


If you reside in South Florida, the Caribbean, or Latin America, you need a roof that offers real protection from hurricanes, tropical storms, and other inclement weather events. Metal roofing is comparatively far stronger than asphalt shingles. A major pro associated with metal roofs is protection. In contrast, asphalt roofs, while they are fine under normal weather conditions, perform somewhat poorly when facing especially harsh weather. If you choose to go with an asphalt roof, you should factor the possibility of repair costs down the road.

Durability (Lifespan)

Different roofing materials have radically different lifespans. A huge benefit of a metal roof is that the average metal roof lasts 50 to 60 years, or longer. Further, little or no maintenance is required during this period. In fact, many metal roofing suppliers offer 50-year-long warranties, no questions asked. In comparison, an asphalt roof typically only lasts for between 15 and 20 years. As a general rule, you will have to replace your asphalt shingles at least once, probably even twice, before you have to do any real repair work on your metal roofing. This is a drawback of putting up asphalt shingles.

Impact on Home Resale Value

Finally, different types of roofing materials can have a disparate impact on a property’s resale value. Typically, the more durable and longer lasting the roof, the more value it will add to your property. Most studies estimate that you will immediately recoup about 80 percent of the cost of a metal roof simply as a result of the increased property value. In comparison, studies suggest that you will recoup somewhat less, usually around 65 percent, of the cost of an asphalt roof in increased property value.

Why Choose Metal Master Shop for Your Metal Roof

For many people, metal roofing is simply a better overall option than asphalt shingles. The initial cost is an investment into a long-lasting, valuable roof. If you are ready to start your next metal roofing project, it is essential that you work with a trusted and reliable supplier. At Metal Master Shop, we are proud to be the top metal roofing company in Miami. We are committed to providing the best services and products to our clients. Among other things, we offer:

  • Truly superior metal roofing products and metal roofing accessories;
  • The ability to customize a metal roof to suit unique projects;
  • The best customer support services in the industry; and
  • Competitive rates that will not break your budget.

Our metal roofing professionals can provide you with a comprehensive quote for your specific needs. If you have a complicated or customized project, we encourage you to give us a call right away. We will find the metal roofing solution that works best for you.

Work With Miami’s Premier Metal Roofing Company

At Metal Master Shop, we offer superior metal roofing services to clients in Miami, South Florida, and internationally. To get a free quote for your next metal roofing project, please fill out our quick request form today. Should you have any specific questions, you can contact our metal roofing professionals for immediate assistance. We are more than happy to help!